ProRes RAW Explained – Plus Footage

At this NAB show, we caught up with Atomos’ Jeromy Young and he walks us through the brand new ProRes RAW format and everything there is to know about it. Let’s dive right in!

ProRes RAW
ProRes has always been the go-to standard (on a Mac, at least) when it comes to NLE-friendly postproduction workflows since it’s not only an aquisition codec but an intermediate and possibly a delivery codec as well. The all-new ProRes RAW is no exception, it’s RAW for the masses.

Apple ProRes RAW

Atomos and Apple have teamed up to develop this new format. It’s designed to simplify and streamline the sometimes cumberstone RAW workflow. Every camera manufacturer has its own RAW format and you’ll need to adapt to all kinds of workflows here. The only exception would be cinemaDNG here but that’s not a very NLE-friendly format, too. ProRes RAW, on the other hand, has usability right built-in. It is designed to cover everything from capturing straight to editing and grading. It gets you the usability of ProRes combined with the flexibility of RAW. But keep in mind: Only Apple FinalCut Pro X 10.4.1 supports this new format for the time being. Others will follow, that’s for sure.

ProRes RAW

Sensor data processed in-camera.

Video cameras normally process the RAW sensor data (individual sensels in a Bayer pattern) internally and create RGB video pixels which are then being compressed to the recording codec. The processing is baked in and can not be manipulated afterwards. The ProRes RAW workflow on the other hand takes all the RAW data and records it straight to the ProRes RAW format. This enables you to manipulate the demosaicing within FinalCut Pro X. Since the ProRes format is NLE-friendly, no additional rendering or transcoding is needed. You can start editing, grading and fine-tuning right away.

ProRes RAW

ProRes RAW workflow.

Two flavours of this new format are available: ProRes RAW could be seen as the equivalent to ProRes 422 HQ in terms of data rate. And then there is ProRes RAW HQ, which is the ProRes 4444 XQ of RAW. We’re looking at a compressed RAW format here and this actually makes a lot of sense. Uncompressed 12-Bit RAW will urge the need of bringing vast arrays of very fast SSDs to your shoots in order to keep up with the data rate.

If you want to dig deeper in to the inner workings of ProRes RAW, this whitepaper (PDF) created by Apple might be worth a closer look.

Atomos, Apple & DJI

The more recent Atomos monitors/recorders have ProRes RAW support built-in already. You can download new firmware versions which enable the support for ProRes RAW for the Shogun Inferno and Sumo 19 monitors/recorders right now. You can download these here. These firmware updates enable you to record very high quality RAW data up to 12-Bit (depends on your cameras’ capabilities, of course) straight to ProRes RAW. Furthermore the freshly announced Atomos Ninja V is at least capable of recording ProRes RAW, too. It’s not licensed for that yet but I guess it’s only a matter of time (and a matter of cameras being able to output RAW over HDMI).

ProRes RAW

A bunch of cinema cameras capable of outputting RAW data. Is yours among them?

DJI have some updates ready for their X7 camera, too. You’ll need to wait just a littler for this, though. It should be ready in May this year. I’d say compressed and ready-to-edit RAW straight from a very portable drone camera sounds pretty impressive!

All in all ProRes RAW could be the solution for others to follow. No more different proprietary RAW formats for each and every camera and no more ridiculously large file sizes with uncompressed RAW formats. Let’s see where this is leading us in terms of RAW and HDR workflows.

Links: Apple whitepaper (PDF) | Atomos.com | DJI.com

What do you think of this move by Apple? Does RAW finally become mainstream? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

Leave a Comment

You are not subscribed to this post. Follow new comments

Login to comment

Reply
Crimson Son April 13, 2018

But can you control white point and ISO for the ProRes RAW file? As I understand it, this cannot be done other than using the built-in debayer in FCPX.
If that is the case then 4444 might still be the better format if PQ is the primary concern.

Reply
Funky Punky Monkey Junk April 16, 2018

Those are only metadata when you’re shooting raw. You choose an ISO on the camera when shooting, so you can calculate aperture and shutter speed for your chosen ISO. The camera then tags the file with the ISO you selected.

But the file only contains luminance data for each photosite on the camera’s sensor; that’s why it’s called “raw.” All of your other choices are made when converting the data to RGB.

Gregory Arvanitis Reply
Gregory Arvanitis April 14, 2018

Roger

Reply
Funky Punky Monkey Junk April 16, 2018

(random name)

Or did you have an actual COMMENT?

Reply
Ajit Patel April 14, 2018

Hi,
Does one have to shoot exclusively in log to use the prores raw?

Reply
John Eubanks April 14, 2018

I have the Canon C500. If I am reading this right it will suit my needs perfectly. The question is, will this allow me to record 4k Raw at 60P to Pro Res Raw, and 4k Half Raw at 120P to pro res raw with a Shogun Inferno from a C500? I don’t think they fully updated their website and the Shogun spec sheets yet, so I’m a bit confused.

Thanks!

Reply
Stephane Shogun April 14, 2018

I just hope that it will come out on the new BMPCC 4K. Thanks for the report guys!

Reply
Thibault Menu April 14, 2018

How is it different from redcode raw or arri raw ?
You say it is no longer a proprietary raw codec but it comes from Apple so I guess it won’t be so easy and cheap for other brands to use it… Windows users stil can’t export in prores
Looks really good though and I can’t wait to try it on my dji x7 !

Olaf von Voss Reply
Olaf von Voss April 14, 2018

Thibault Menu,

I agree with you. Sure, in the end it’s a proprietary format by Apple, but it has the potential to unify the different RAW formats from all kinds of cameras.
Let’s hope they make it available to as many manufacturers as possible at a reasonable price. Anything else would defeat the purpose.

All the best
Olaf

Reply
Thibault Menu April 14, 2018

Yeah I guess it’s all up to them.
Thanks for the coverage by the way !
And this guy from Atomos is awesome ! He was as excited on all the interviews I saw, way to go !

Reply
Kevin Duffey April 16, 2018

So while ProRes RAW sounds awesome.. a huge number of editors/et all work on Windows. Especially given the horrible specs of the top of the line macbook pro compared to windows based laptops already available and new ones with even more capabilities soon.

So..with that in mind, given how bad ProRes performs on PCs, when is there going to be a DNxHR RAW equivalent? In the past year, more and more clients are switching and asking for DNxHR as they understand Macbook/apple is going out of flavor for in the field work and DNxHR being open and available on all platforms is a no brainer choice to ensure whoever you work with regardless of OS/hardware, it will work.

So.. is there any info regarding an updated DNxHR RAW codec?

Oscar M Reply
Oscar M April 17, 2018

So the good old FS700 can be a mean prores raw machine with just a Inferno via SDI is that correct- :)